Between the Fronts
The Russian Left’s Opposition to the »Special Operation« in Ukraine
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.32387/prokla.v52i208.2008Keywords:
Russia, Ukraine, Social Democracy, Anarchism, Trotzkyism, Post-Soviet UnionAbstract
The left opposition in Russia is divided on the question of war. The article focuses on those left actors who opposed Putin’s decision to attack Ukraine militarily. The differences to the situation in 2014 are striking. There are hardly any hopes left for revolutionary developments in the neighbouring state and even more fears.
Downloads
References
Anarchistická Federace (2022): A sidenote to one statement The Internationale of Anarchist Federations has made a statement on the war in Ukraine, but we consider it insufficient (18.4.2022). URL: https://www.afed.cz/text/7638/a-sidenote-to-one-statement, Zugriff: 10.7.2022.
Anton, Felix (2022): »Wir brauchen einen Partisanenkampf« – Perspektiven eines russischen Genossen auf den Krieg in der Ukraine (7.4.2022). URL: https://lowerclassmag.com/2022/04/07/wir-brauchen-einen-partisanenkampf-perspektiven-eines-russischen-genossen-auf-den-krieg-in-der-ukraine/, Zugriff: 10.7.2022.
Batov, Aleksandr (2022): My protiv vojny, I ne otstupim (28.2.2022). URL: https://rabkor.ru/columns/editorial-columns/2022/02/28/we_are_against_war_and_we_wont_back_down/, Zugriff: 21.7.2022.
Brudny, Yitzhak M. (2000): Reinventing Russia: Russian Nationalism and the Soviet State, 1953–1991. Cambridge.
Critisticuffs (2022): Stop conflating Ukraine and its inhabitants. URL: https://critisticuffs.org/texts/stop-conflating-ukraine-and-its-inhabitants, Zugriff: 10.7.2022.
Feminists Against War: (2022): Feminist Resistance Against War. A Manifesto (17.3.2022). URL: https://spectrejournal.com/feminist-resistance-against-war/ , Zugriff: 10.7.2022.
Feminist Anti-War Resistance (2022): Russia’s Feminists Are in the Streets Protesting Putin’s War (27.02.2022). URL: https://jacobin.com/2022/02/russian-feminist-antiwar-resistance-ukraine-putin, Zugriff: 10.7.2022.
Gelderloos, Peter (2022): The Invasion Of Ukraine: Anarchist Interventions And Geopolitical Changes (14.3.2022). URL: https://itsgoingdown.org/the-invasion-of-ukraine-anarchist-interventions-and-geopolitical-changes/, Zugriff: 10.7.2022.
Hashim, Syed Mohsin (1999): KPRF Ideology and Its Implications for Democratization in Russia. In: Communist and Post-Communist Studies 32: 77-89. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0967-067X(98)00023-3.
Konstantinow, Simon (2022): »Die Repression hat eine neue Stufe erreicht« – Anna von der linken Organisation Sozialistitscheskaja Alternatiwa über die Antikriegsproteste in Russland In: analyse & kritik 680. URL: https://www.akweb.de/politik/antikriegsproteste-in-russland-die-repression-hat-eine-neue-stufe-erreicht/, Zugriff: 10.7.2022.
KRAS-IAA (2022): KRAS-IAA über den Krieg in der Ukraine (15.3.2022). URL: https://iwa-ait.org/content/kras-iaa-uber-den-krieg-der-ukraine, Zugriff: 10.7.2022.
Kurnaševskij, Boris (2014): Nekotorye ukrainskie levye i vojna v Dobasse (25.7.-27.08.2014). URL: http://saint-juste.narod.ru/Ukrainskie_levye.html, Zugriff: 10.7.2022.
Kuz’min, Vasilij (2018): Komsomol imeni Letova. Hroniki soprotivlenija pod flagom AKM. Moskau.
Laurelle, Marlene (2009): Russian Nationalism. Imaginaries, Doctrines, and Political Battlefield. London/New York.
Marksistskaja Tendencija (2022): Net vojne s Ukrainoj! Protiv voennoj intervencii Rossii (24.2.2022). URL: https://marxist.news/novosti/rossijskie-novosti/net-vojne-s-ukrainoj-protiv-voennoj-intervenczii-rossii/, Zugriff: 10.7.2022.
Martin, Terry (2001): The Affirmative Action Empire. Nations and nationalism in the Soviet Union, 1923-1939. Ithaca. DOI: https://doi.org/10.7591/9781501713323.
Miller, Aleksej (2000): »Ukrainskij vopros« v politike vlastej i russkom obš?estvennom menenii (vtoraja polovina XIX veka). St. Petersburg.
Platonenko, Vladmir (2022): O vojne s Ukrainoj (9.3.2022). URL: https://www.avtonom.org/author_columns/o-voyne-s-ukrainoy, Zugriff: 10.7.2022.
Putilov, Egor (2014): Karmannye revoljucionery (18.9.2014). URL: https://www.colta.ru/articles/society/4683-karmannye-revolyutsionery, Zugriff: 10.7.2022.
Putin, Vladimir (2021): Ob istori?eskom edinsteve russkih i ukraincev (12.7.2021). URL: http://kremlin.ru/events/president/news/66181, Zugriff: 10.7.2022.
Sachnin, Aleksej (2022): Po?emu ja vyhožu iz Levyj Front? In: Rabkor.ru (27.2.2022). URL: https://rabkor.ru/columns/left/2022/02/27/why_am_i_leaving_the_left_front/, Zugriff: 10.7.2022.
Schewtschenko, Maxim (2022): »Die Kommunistische Partei ist eine chauvinistische Kraft«. In: Konkret 7/2022: 22-24.
Socialisti?eskaja al’ternativa (2022): Ugroza vojny I zaš?ita Ukrainy. Rossija i NATO – von iz Vosto?noj Evropy! (26.1.2022). URL: https://socialist.news/world/ukraine/threat-war-and-defense/, Zugriff: 10.7.2022.
Sokolov, Michail (2022): Ukraina i levy rskol (17.10.2014). URL: https://www.svoboda.org/a/26640489.html, Zugriff: 10.7.2022
Sozialistische Alternative (2022): Nein zum Krieg (25.2.2022). URL: https://www.sozialismus.info/2022/02/nein-zum-krieg/, Zugriff: 10.7.2022.
Tarasov, Aleksandr (2014): Kakoj harakter nosit vojna na Donbasse? Neobhodimoe zame?anie k stat’e B. Kurnaševskogo, 28.-29.08.2014. URL: http://saint-juste.narod.ru/Kakoj_harakter.html, Zugriff: 10.7.2022.
The Insider [o.A.]: Denacifikatory zdorovogo ?eloveka. Kak antifa I anarhisty borjutsja s putinskim vtorženiem / Denazification done right: How Russian anti-fascists and anarchists are battling Putin’s invasion (18.5.2022). URL: https://theins.ru/en/politics/251492, Zugriff: 10.7.2022.
Urban, Joan Barth / Solovei, Valerii D. (1997): Russia’s Communists at the Crossroads. Boulder.
Volodarskij, Aleksandr (2014): Levye razdelennyje Maidanom (14.7.2014). URL: http://left.by/archives/2438, Zugriff: 10.7.2022.
Weinmann, Ute (2015): Von Befreiung keine Spur: kritische Perspektiven auf die Konflikte um den Donbass und die Krim. Berlin.